Secret Obsession (2019)

Movie Name/Year: Secret Obsession (2019)

Genre: Drama, Thriller

Length: 97 minutes

Rating: NR

Production/Distribution: Hybrid, Netflix

Director: Peter Sullivan

Writer: Peter Sullivan, Kraig Wenman

Actors: Brenda Song, Mike Vogel, Dennis Haysbert, Ashley Scott, Paul Sloan, Daniel Booko, Scott Peat, Blair Hickey, Michael Patrick McGill, Casey Leach, Jim Hanna, Ciarra Carter, Eric Etebari

Blurb from IMDb: Recuperating from trauma, Jennifer remains in danger as she returns to a life she doesn't remember.

Selina’s Point of View:

I don’t often get to go into why a movie didn’t make my Top 20 for whatever month it came out. Generally, by the time I see the film I’ve forgotten exactly what month it hit theaters (or streaming) unless it was one I was looking forward to. For Secret Obsession, I have the unique opportunity of knowing exactly when it came out, because it hit Netflix yesterday.

We do get a lot of questions about why we choose, or don’t choose, certain films for our Top 20. The truth is, we use only the information available to any prospective viewer when deciding what movies we should recommend for the coming month. That means that we have the trailer, basic search engines, and the IMDb page. Quite frankly, the trailer is usually worth more than the rest of what we see.

In this case, Secret Obsession was really hurt by the preview.

Upon viewing the trailer I was instantly reminded of another film we watched – one that I didn’t find all that spectacular. It was easy to think that Before I Go to Sleep (2014) could have very well been what Secret Obsession was trying to be. Nothing set it apart. Worse than that, it felt like the film shoved every twist and moment of intrigue into the coming attraction.

Like anyone else, it’s possible – even easy – to get it wrong. Sometimes things will go on the Top 20 that turn out to be crap, other times I overlook stuff that winds up being amazing. In this case, I was right – and so was Cat.

This film didn’t try to raise the bar at all. It had no surprises and you could play trope bingo while watching.

Secret Obsession was mediocre at best. Any thrilling moments, all the twists, it was all spoiled in the trailer. You can watch two minutes of teaser on YouTube and not have to waste an hour and a half.

Cat’s Point of View:

Before I mention my take on the movie, I have a bit of a bone to pick with Netflix. The industry, in general, has a nasty habit of triggering this pet peeve – but for now, let’s focus on this instance.

The streaming giant often splashes up a big promo for imminent releases. Whether it’s the trailer that is set to auto-play a few seconds after credits roll on the show you’ve just finished or the big banners you see when you first sign in – it’s quite effective in grabbing subscribers’ attention. This trailer was plastered all over the place a few days ago. I'd forgotten this preview from our Top 20 selection process, and so I opted to watch it again with the prompt.

Way to go, Netflix. Thanks for the spoilers. What should have been a spine-tingling moment to evoke a sense of dread and alarm in the pit of my stomach in concern for the fate of the protagonist became just another tense moment in the film to blend with the rest of the suspenseful music and so on. It completely stole the thunder of the scene.

Needless to say, if you want to be surprised? Don’t watch the trailer for this movie if you don't want to know ALL THE THINGS.

I digress.

Brenda Song (The Social Network, Boogie Town, Amphibia) has come a long way from her Disney days. It’s no secret that she can handle physical roles, though, considering her early work included Wendy Wu: Homecoming Warrior (2005). I’m happy to see her in more serious roles such as this. I really enjoyed her character. It’s about time movies are showing more situations where damsels in distress use their common sense and survival instincts to try to help themselves instead of giving up and resigning themselves to be a victim.

I really appreciated Mike Vogel (McCanick, Under The Dome, The Brave) for the role of Russell. He can turn on the charm, but also carries the darker stuff rather well too. He was a good pick for the physicality of this part, as well.

There’s a bonus with this cast – one of my favorite ‘hey it’s that guy!’ people. Dennis Haysbert (The Unit, Think Like a Man Too, Experimenter) wasn’t here to sell us any insurance, even though the role of the detective was in good hands. (Not sorry.) If you don’t recognize him from some of his prior work, like playing the president on 24 (2001-2010), surely you’ve heard his voice.

I feel like there were a few plot holes that weren’t quite filled in, and the ending didn’t offer exactly the satisfaction I was looking for.

Even though I knew what was coming, or could guess well enough (thanks Netflix), I still found myself practically holding my breath in a few places and feeling that sense of urgency that spurs talking to the screen as if the characters might listen.

The story was a bit like Before I Go to Sleep (2014) but had quite a few differences. If it hadn’t been spoiled, perhaps I might not feel like someone copied this test but changed enough answers so it wouldn’t be blatantly cheating. 

All told, I enjoyed this movie, but not as much as if I’d been able to go into the film with a clean slate.   

Rotten Tomatoes Critic Score – None

Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score – None

Metascore – None

Metacritic User Score – None

IMDB Score – 4.5/10

CinemaScore – None

Trust the Dice: Selina’s Rating – 2/5

Trust the Dice: Cat’s Rating – 2.5/5

Trust-the-Dice’s Parental Advisory Rating: PG-13

Movie Trailer: